Supplementing REDD+ with Biodiversity Payments: The Paradox of Paying for Multiple Ecosystem Services

References

1. ↵
   1. Andersen Lykke,
   2. Busch Jonah,
   3. Curren Elizabeth,
   4. Ledezma Juan Carlos,
   5. Mayorga Joaquín,
   6. Bellier Mélissa

   . 2012. “Environmental and Socio-economic Consequences of Forest Carbon Payments in Bolivia: Results of the OSIRIS-Bolivia Model.” Development Research Working Paper Series 02/2012. La Paz, Bolivia: Institute for Advanced Development Studies (INESAD).
2. ↵
   1. Bode Michael,
   2. Watson James,
   3. Iwamura Takuya,
   4. Possingham Hugh P.

   2008. “The Cost of Conservation.” Science 321 (5887): 340. doi: 10.1126/science.321.5887.340a.

   OpenUrlCrossRef
3. ↵
   1. Boitani L.,
   2. Catullo G.,
   3. Marzetti I.,
   4. Masi M.,
   5. Rulli M.,
   6. Savini S.

   2006. The Southeast Asian Mammal Databank. A Tool for Conservation and Monitoring of Mammal Diversity in Southeast Asia. Rome: Istituto di Ecologia Applicata.
4. ↵
   1. Börner Jan,
   2. Wunder Sven,
   3. Wertz-Kanounnikoff Sheila,
   4. Tito Marcos R.,
   5. Pereira Ligia,
   6. Nascimento Nathalia

   . 2010. “Direct Conservation Payments in the Brazilian Amazon: Scope and Equity Implications.” Ecological Economics 69 (6): 1272–82.

   OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
5. ↵
   1. Busch Jonah,
   2. Godoy Fabiano,
   3. Turner Will R.,
   4. Harvey Celia A.

   2011. “Biodiversity Co-benefits of Reducing Emissions from Deforestation under Alternative Reference Levels and Levels of Finance.” Conservation Letters 4 (2): 101–15.

   OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
6. ↵
   1. Busch Jonah,
   2. Lubowski Ruben N.,
   3. Godoy Fabiano,
   4. Steininger Marc,
   5. Yusuf Arief A.,
   6. Austin Kemen,
   7. Hewson Jenny,
   8. Juhn Daniel,
   9. Farid Muhammad,
   10. Boltz Frederick

   . 2012. “Structuring Economic Incentives to Reduce Emissions from Deforestation within Indonesia.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences U S A. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1109034109.

   OpenUrlCrossRef
7. ↵
   1. Busch Jonah,
   2. Strassburg Bernardo,
   3. Cattaneo Andrea,
   4. Lubowski Ruben,
   5. Bruner Aaron,
   6. Rice Richard,
   7. Creed Anna,
   8. Ashton Ralph,
   9. Boltz Frederick

   . 2009. “Comparing Climate and Cost Impacts of Reference Levels for Reducing Emissions from Deforestation.” Environmental Research Letters 4 (Oct.–Dec.): 044006.
8. ↵
   1. Carswell Fiona,
   2. Burrows Larry

   . 2006. “Could Biodiversity Add Value to New Zealand’s Kyoto Forest Credits?” New Zealand Journal of Forestry 51 (2): 31–33.

   OpenUrl
9. ↵
   1. Castro Rocio,
   2. Hammond Brian

   . 2009. “The Architecture of Aid for the Environment: A Ten Year Statistical Perspective.” CFP Working Paper Series No. 3.Washington, DC: Concessional Finance and Global Partnerships Vice Presidency, World Bank Group.
10. ↵
    1. Cattaneo Andrea,
    2. Daniel Hellerstein,
    3. Nickerson Cynthia J.,
    4. Myers Christina

    . 2006. Balancing the Multiple Objectives of Conservation Programs. Economic Research Report 19. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Agriculture.
11. ↵
    1. Cerbu Gillian A.,
    2. Swallow Brent M.,
    3. Thompson Dara Y.

    2010. “Locating REDD: A Global Survey and Analysis of REDD Readiness and Demonstration Activities.” Environmental Science and Policy 14 (2): 168–80. doi: 10.1016/j.envsci.2010.09.007.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
12. ↵
    1. Collins M. B.,
    2. Milner-Gulland E. J.,
    3. Macdonald E. A.,
    4. Macdonald D. W.

    2011. “Pleiotropy and Charisma Determine Winners and Losers in the REDD+ Game: All Biodiversity Is Not Equal.” Tropical Conservation Science 4 (3): 261–66.

    OpenUrl
13. ↵
    1. Conte Marc N.,
    2. Kotchen Matthew J.

    2010. “Explaining the Price of Voluntary Carbon Offsets.” Climate Change Economics 1 (2): 93–111.

    OpenUrl
14. ↵
    1. da Fonseca Gustavo A. B.,
    2. Rodriguez Carlos Manuel,
    3. Midgley Guy,
    4. Busch Jonah,
    5. Hannah Lee,
    6. Mittermeier Russell A.

    2007. “No Forest Left Behind.” PLoS Biology 5 (8): 1645–46.

    OpenUrlWeb of Science
15. ↵
    1. de Kooning Free,
    2. Aguiñaga Marcela,
    3. Bravo Manuel,
    4. Chiu Marco,
    5. Lascano Max,
    6. Lozada Tannya,
    7. Suarez Luis

    . 2011. “Bridging the Gap between Forest Conservation and Poverty Alleviation: The Ecuadorian Socio Bosque Program.” Environmental Science and Policy 14 (5): 531–42. doi: 10.1016/j.envsci.2011.04.007.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
16. ↵
    1. Dinerstein Eric,
    2. Varma Keshav,
    3. Wikramanayake Eric,
    4. Lumpkin Susan

    . 2010. Wildlife Premium Market + REDD: Creating a Financial Incentive for Conservation and Recovery of Endangered Species and Habitats. Wildlife Premium Concept Document. Available at www.hcvnetwork.org/resources/folder.2006-09-29.6584228415/Wildlife_Premium-REDD%20Oct%2013%202010%20-2-%20-2.pdf (accessed April 3, 2012).
17. ↵
    1. Ferraro Paul J.

    2007. “Asymmetric Information and Contract Design for Payments for Environmental Services.” Ecological Economics 65 (4): 810–21.

    OpenUrl
18. ↵
    1. Forest Carbon Partnership Facility

    .2012. Recommendations of the Working Group on the Methodological and Pricing Approach for the Carbon Fund of the FCPF. Revised Final Draft, June 9. FMT Note 2012-8. Available at www.forestcarbonpartnership.org/fcp/sites/forestcarbonpartnership.org/files/Documents/PDF/June2012/FMT%20Note%202012-8%20Working%20Group%20Recomm%2006-09-12%20EN_0.pdf (accessed June18, 2012).
19. ↵
    1. Gardner Toby A.,
    2. Burgess Neil D.,
    3. Aguilar-Amuchastegui Naikoa,
    4. Barlow Jos,
    5. Berenguer Erika,
    6. Clements Tom,
    7. Danielsen Finn,
    8. Ferreira Joice,
    9. Foden Wendy,
    10. Kapos Valerie,
    11. et al.

    2012. “A Framework for Integrating Biodiversity Concerns into National REDD+ Programmes.” Biological Conservation 154 (Oct.): 61–71. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2011.11.018.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
20. ↵
    1. Gibbs Holly K.,
    2. Brown Sandra

    . 2007. Geographical Distribution of Biomass Carbon in Tropical Southeast Asian Forests: An Updated Database for 2000.Oak Ridge, TN: Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Available at http://cdiac.ornl.gov/epubs/ndp/ndp068/ndp068b.html.
21. ↵
    Government of Guyana and Government of Norway. 2009. Joint Concept Note on REDD+ Cooperation between Guyana and Norway.
22. ↵
    1. Gregersen Hans,
    2. Lakany Hosny El,
    3. Karsenty Alain,
    4. White Andy

    . 2010. Does the Opportunity Cost Approach Indicate the Real Cost of REDD+? Rights and Realities of Paying for REDD+. Washington, DC: Rights and Resources Initiative.
23. ↵
    1. Grieg-Gran Maryanne

    . 2006. The Cost of Avoiding Deforestation. Report prepared for the Stern Review of the economics of climate change. London: International Institute for Environment and Development.
24. ↵
    1. Gutman P.,
    2. Davidson S.

    2008. A Review of Innovative International Financial Mechanisms for Biodiversity Conservation. Gland, Switzerland: World Wide Fund for Nature.
25. ↵
    1. Halpern Benjamin S.,
    2. Pyke Christopher R.,
    3. Fox Helen E.,
    4. Haney J. Chris,
    5. Schlaepfer Martin A.,
    6. Zaradic Patricia

    . 2006. “Gaps and Mismatches between Global Conservation Priorities and Spending.” Conservation Biology 20 (1): 56–64.

    OpenUrlCrossRefPubMedWeb of Science
26. ↵
    1. Hansen Matthew C.,
    2. Stehman Stephen V.,
    3. Potapov Peter V.,
    4. Arunarwati Belinda,
    5. Stolle Fred,
    6. Pittman Kyle

    . 2009. “Quantifying Changes in the Rates of Forest Clearing in Indonesia from 1990 to 2005 Using Remotely Sensed Data Sets.” Environmental Research Letters 4 (3). doi:10.1088/1748-9326/4/3/034001.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
27. ↵
    1. Hansen Matthew C.,
    2. Stehman Stephen V.,
    3. Potapov Peter V.,
    4. Loveland Thomas R.,
    5. Townshend John R. G.,
    6. DeFries Ruth S.,
    7. Pittman Kyle W.,
    8. Arunarwati Belinda,
    9. Stolle Fred,
    10. Steininger Marc K.,
    11. et al.

    2008. “Humid Tropical Forest Clearing from 2000 to 2005 Quantified Using Multi-temporal and Multi-resolution Remotely Sensed Data.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences U S A 105 (27): 9439–44.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
28. ↵
    1. Harvey Celia A.,
    2. Dickson Barney,
    3. Kormos Cyril

    . 2010. “Opportunities for Achieving Biodiversity Conservation through REDD.” Conservation Letters 3 (1): 53–61.

    OpenUrl
29. ↵
    1. International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)

    . 2011. IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Version 2011.2. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN. Available at www.iucnredlist.org (accessed March 2012).
30. ↵
    1. Kapos V.,
    2. Ravilious C.,
    3. Campbell A.,
    4. Dickson B.,
    5. Gibbs H.,
    6. Hansen M.,
    7. Lysenko I.,
    8. Miles L.,
    9. Price J.,
    10. Scharlemann J. P.W.,
    11. et al.

    2008. Carbon and Biodiversity: A Demonstration Atlas. Cambridge, UK: UNEP-WCMC.
31. ↵
    1. Killeen Timothy J.,
    2. Calderon Veronica,
    3. Soria Liliana,
    4. Quezada Belem,
    5. Steininger Marc K.,
    6. Harper Grady,
    7. Solórzano Luis A.,
    8. Tucker Compton J.

    2007. “Thirty Years of Land-Cover Change in Bolivia.” Ambio 36 (7): 600–6.

    OpenUrlPubMed
32. ↵
    1. Kremen Claire,
    2. Cameron Alison,
    3. Razafimpahanana Andriamandimbisoa,
    4. Moilanen Atte,
    5. Thomas Chris D.,
    6. Beentje Henk,
    7. Dransfield John,
    8. Fisher Brian L.,
    9. Glaw Frank,
    10. Good Tatjana C.,
    11. et al.

    2008. “Conservation with Caveats: Response.” Science 321 (5887): 341–42. doi: 10.1126/science.321.5887.340b.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
33. ↵
    1. Larsen Frank W.,
    2. Londoño-Murcia Maria C.,
    3. Turner Will R.

    2011. “Global Priorities for Conservation of Threatened Species, Carbon Storage, and Freshwater Services: Scope for Synergy?” Conservation Letters 4 (5): 355–63. doi: 10.1111/j.1755–263X.2011.00183.x.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
34. ↵
    1. Mankiw N. Gregory

    . 2008. Principles of Macroeconomics. 5th ed. Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.
35. ↵
    1. Miles Lera,
    2. Kapos Valerie

    . 2008. “Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation: Global Land-Use Implications.” Science 320 (5882): 1454–55.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
36. ↵
    1. Ministère de l’Environnement des Forets et du Tourisme (MEFT),
    2. U.S. Agency for International Development, and Conservation International

    . 2009. Évolution de la couverture de forêts naturelles à Madagascar. Antananarivo, Madagascar: Conservation International.
37. ↵
    1. Ministry of Environment, Norway

    .2010. Norway and the Amazon Fund: Facts about the Rainforest and the Amazon Fund. Available at www.regjeringen.no/en/dep/md/Selected-topics/climate/the-government-of-norways-international-/norway-amazonfund.html?id=593978 (accessed November 20, 2010).
38. ↵
    1. Muñoz-Piña Carlos,
    2. Guevara Alejandro,
    3. Torres Juan Manuel,
    4. Braña Josefina

    . 2007. “Paying for the Hydrological Services of Mexico’s Forests: Analysis, Negotiations and Results.” Ecological Economics 65 (4): 725–36.

    OpenUrl
39. ↵
    1. Naidoo Robin,
    2. Iwamura Takuya

    . 2007. “Global-Scale Mapping of Economic Benefits from Agricultural Lands: Implications for Conservation Priorities.” Biological Conservation 140 (1–2): 40–49.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
40. ↵
    1. Neeff Till,
    2. Ashford Lisa,
    3. Calvert Jeff,
    4. Davey Claire,
    5. Durbin Joanna,
    6. Ebeling Johannes,
    7. Herrera Tilde,
    8. Janson-Smith Toby,
    9. Lazo Bernardo,
    10. Mountain Rachel,
    11. et al.

    2009. The Forest Carbon Offsetting Survey 2009. Dublin, Ireland: EcoSecurities.
41. ↵
    1. Nelson Erik,
    2. Mendoza Guillermo,
    3. Regetz James,
    4. Polasky Stephen,
    5. Tallis Heather,
    6. Cameron D. Richard,
    7. Chan Kai M. A.,
    8. Daily Gretchen C.,
    9. Goldstein Joshua,
    10. Kareiva Peter M.,
    11. et al.

    2009. “Modeling Multiple Ecosystem Services, Biodiversity Conservation, Commodity Production, and Tradeoffs at Landscape Scales.” Frontiers in Ecology and Environment 7 (1): 4–11.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
42. ↵
    1. Nelson Erik,
    2. Polasky Stephen,
    3. Lewis David J.,
    4. Plantinga Andrew J.,
    5. Lonsdorf Eric,
    6. White Denis,
    7. Bael David,
    8. Lawler Joshua J.

    2008. “Efficiency of Incentives to Jointly Increase Carbon Sequestration and Species Conservation on a Landscape.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences U S A 105 (28): 9471–76.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
43. ↵
    1. Nowicki C.,
    2. Ley A.,
    3. Caballero R.,
    4. Sommer J. H.,
    5. Barthlott W.,
    6. Ibisch P. L.

    2004. “Extrapolating Distribution Ranges: BIOM 1.1., a Computerized Bio-climatic Model for the Extrapolation of Species Ranges and Diversity Patterns.” In Orchids of Bolivia: Diversity and Conservation Status, ed. Vásquez R. Ch., Ibisch P. L., 39–68. Vol. 2. Laeliinae, Polystachinae, Sobraliinae with Update and Complementation of the Pleurothallidinae. Santa Cruz de la Sierra, Bolivia: Editorial FAN.

    OpenUrl
44. ↵
    1. Obersteiner Michael,
    2. Rametsteiner Ewald,
    3. Kraxner Florian,
    4. McCallum Ian,
    5. Aoki Kentaro,
    6. Boettcher Hannes,
    7. Fritz Steffen,
    8. Gusti Mykola,
    9. Havlik Petr,
    10. Kindermann Georg,
    11. et al.

    2010. “Towards a Sound REDD: Ensuring Globally Consistent Reference Scenarios and Safeguarding Sustainability Co-benefits.” In Deforestation and Climate Change: Reducing Carbon Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation, ed. Bosetti V., Lubowski R. Milan, Italy: Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei.
45. ↵
    1. Paoli Gary D.,
    2. Wells Philip L.,
    3. Meijaard Erik,
    4. Struebig Matthew J.,
    5. Marshall Andrew J.,
    6. Obidzinski Krystof,
    7. Tan Aseng,
    8. Rafiastanto Andjar,
    9. Yaap Betsy,
    10. Slik J. W. Ferry,
    11. et al.

    2010. “Biodiversity Conservation in the REDD.” Carbon Balance and Management 5: 7.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
46. ↵
    1. Putz F. E.,
    2. Redford K. H.

    2009. “Dangers of Carbon-Based Conservation.” Global Environmental Change 19 (4): 400–1.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
47. ↵
    1. Raven Peter H.

    1988. “Our Diminishing Tropical Forests.” In Biodiversity, ed. Wilson Edward O. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
48. ↵
    1. Ring Irene,
    2. Drechsler Martin,
    3. van Teeffelen Astrid J. A.,
    4. Irawan Silvia,
    5. Venter Oscar

    . 2010. “Biodiversity Conservation and Climate Mitigation: What Role Can Economic Instruments Play?” Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 2 (1–2): 50–58.

    OpenUrl
49. ↵
    1. Ruesch Aaron,
    2. Gibbs Holly K.

    2008. New IPCC Tier-1 Global Biomass Carbon Map for the Year 2000. Oak Ridge, TN: Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN, USA. Available at http://cdiac.ornl.gov/epubs/ndp/global_carbon/carbon_documentation.html.
50. ↵
    1. Sánchez-Azofeifa G. Arturo,
    2. Pfaff Alexander,
    3. Robalino Juan Andres,
    4. Boomhower Judson P.

    2007. “Costa Rica’s Payment for Environmental Services Program: Intention, Implementation, and Impact.” Conservation Biology 21 (5): 1165–73.

    OpenUrlCrossRefPubMedWeb of Science
51. ↵
    1. Sarkar Sahotra,
    2. Pressey Robert L.,
    3. Faith Daniel P.,
    4. Margules Christopher R.,
    5. Fuller Trevon,
    6. Stoms David M.,
    7. Moffett Alexander,
    8. Wilson Kerrie A.,
    9. Williams Kristen J.,
    10. Williams Paul H.,
    11. et al.

    2006. “Biodiversity Conservation Planning Tools: Present Status and Challenges for the Future.” Annual Review of Environment and Resources 31: 123–59.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
52. 1. Sasaki Nophea,
    2. Putz Francis E.

    2009. “Critical Need for New Definitions of ‘Forest’ and ‘Forest Degradation’ in Global Climate Change Agreements.” Conservation Letters 2 (5): 226–232.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
53. ↵
    1. Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity

    . 2009. Connecting Biodiversity and Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation: Report of the Second Ad Hoc Technical Expert Group on Biodiversity and Climate Change. Technical Series No. 41. Montreal, QC: Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity.
54. ↵
    1. Siikamaki Juha,
    2. Newbold Stephen C.

    2012. “Potential Biodiversity Benefits from International Programs to Reduce Carbon Emissions from Deforestation.” Ambio 41 (1): 78–89.

    OpenUrl
55. ↵
    1. Stickler Claudia M.,
    2. Nepstad Daniel C.,
    3. Coe Michael T.,
    4. McGrath David G.,
    5. Rodrigues Hermann O.,
    6. Walker Wayne S.,
    7. Soares-Filho Britaldo S.,
    8. Davidson Eric A.

    2009. “The Potential Ecological Costs and Cobenefits of REDD: A Critical Review and Case Study from the Amazon Region.” Global Change Biology 15 (12): 2803–24.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
56. ↵
    1. Stoneham Gary,
    2. Chaudhri Vivek,
    3. Ha Arthur,
    4. Strappazzon Loris

    . 2003. “Auctions for Conservation Contracts: An Empirical Examination of Victoria’s BushTender Trial.” Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 47 (4): 477–500.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
57. ↵
    1. Strassburg Bernardo B. N.,
    2. Kelly Annabel,
    3. Balmford Andrew,
    4. Davies Richard G.,
    5. Gibbs Holly K.,
    6. Lovett Andrew,
    7. Miles Lera,
    8. Orme C. David L.,
    9. Price Jeff,
    10. Turner R. Kerry,
    11. et al.

    2010. “Global Congruence of Carbon Storage and Biodiversity in Terrestrial Ecosystems.” Conservation Letters 3 (2): 98–105.

    OpenUrlCrossRefWeb of Science
58. ↵
    1. Strassburg Bernardo B. N.,
    2. Rodrigues Ana S. L.,
    3. Gusti Mykola,
    4. Balmford Andrew,
    5. Fritz Steffen,
    6. Obersteiner Michael,
    7. Turner R. Kerry,
    8. Brooks Thomas M.

    2012. “Impacts of Incentives to Reduce Emissions from Deforestation on Global Species Extinctions.” Nature Climate Change 2 (5): 350–55. doi: 10.1038/NCLIMATE1375.

    OpenUrlCrossRef
59. ↵
    1. UNFCCC

    . 2009. Decision 4/CP.15. Methodological Guidance for Activities Relating to Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation and the Role of Conservation, Sustainable Management of Forests and Enhancement of Forest Carbon Stocks in Developing Countries. Bonn, Germany: UNFCCC.
60. ↵
    1. UNFCCC

    . Decision 1/CP.16. Outcome of the Work of the Ad Hoc Working Group on Long-Term Cooperative Action under the Convention. Bonn, Germany: UNFCCC.
61. ↵
    1. van Noordwijk Meine

    .2002. “Scaling Trade-offs between Crop Productivity, Carbon Stocks and Biodiversity in Shifting Cultivation Landscape Mosaics: The FALLOW Model.” Ecological Modeling 149 (1–2): 113–26.

    OpenUrl
62. ↵
    1. Venter Oscar,
    2. Laurance William F.,
    3. Iwamura Takuya,
    4. Wilson Kerrie A.,
    5. Fuller Richare A.,
    6. Possingham Hugh P.

    2009. “Harnessing Carbon Payments to Protect Biodiversity.” Science 326 (5958): 1368.

    OpenUrlAbstract/FREE Full Text
63. ↵
    1. Zoellick Robert

    . 2010. “Advancing REDD+: New Pathways and Partnerships.” Presented at the Avoided Deforestation Side Event, UNFCCC COP 16. Cancun, Mexico, December 8.