Table 4 Consideration-Set-Radius Models without and with Engagement-Intensity Weights and Either Sample-Selection Corrections or Interactions between All Regressors and Demeaned Ordered-Probit Selection Propensities
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)
ModelNaiveWeights OnlyBinary Probit IMROrdered Probit IMRDemeaned Propensity
Main Variable
Empl. Status: employed−0.0351
(0.0696)
−0.0613
(0.0973)
−0.0872
(0.0943)
−0.0934
(0.0936)
−0.299*
(0.154)
Income data available−0.429***
(0.127)
−0.362**
(0.180)
−0.342*
(0.176)
−0.354**
(0.175)
−0.223
(0.186)
ln(Income in 10K, if reported)0.218***
(0.0533)
0.171**
(0.0730)
0.156**
(0.0718)
0.158**
(0.0710)
0.0628
(0.0887)
Gender: female−0.127**
(0.0590)
−0.123
(0.0796)
−0.0374
(0.0787)
−0.0410
(0.0783)
0.000944
(0.106)
Age: <45 years0.185**
(0.0835)
0.225**
(0.112)
0.167
(0.106)
0.137
(0.108)
−0.317
(0.197)
Age: >64 years−0.0489
(0.0713)
−0.114
(0.0982)
−0.0287
(0.100)
−0.103
(0.0961)
−0.0110
(0.115)
Education: graduate school0.113*
(0.0598)
0.0132
(0.0751)
−0.0649
(0.0741)
−0.0642
(0.0748)
−0.259***
(0.0958)
No interest: perching birds−0.811***
(0.148)
−0.862***
(0.198)
−0.847***
(0.205)
−0.829***
(0.202)
−0.749***
(0.190)
No interest: other game birds−0.634***
(0.107)
−0.660***
(0.130)
−0.577***
(0.131)
−0.578***
(0.130)
−0.549***
(0.127)
Constant4.066***
(0.0972)
4.170***
(0.127)
4.494***
(0.135)
4.403***
(0.131)
4.102***
(0.140)
Selection-Correction Strategy
Binary-probit IMR−0.169***
(0.0305)
Ordered probit IMR−0.386***
(0.0689)
Interaction between Main Variables and Demeaned Engagement Propensity (Demeaned Using qBus Sample Mean)
Empl. Status: employed × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.185
(0.158)
Income data avail. × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
−0.120
(00756)
ln(Income in 10K, if reported) × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.134*
(0.0692)
Gender: female × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.224*
(0.117)
Age: <45 years × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
−0.00451
(0.0733)
Age: >64 years × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
−0.0223
(0.0607)
Education: graduate school × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.0176
(0.0551)
No interest: perching birds × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
−0.231
(0.175)
No interest: other game birds × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.160
(0.107)
Constant × engagement prop.
(demeaned)
0.282***
(0.0813)
ln(σε)−0.0803***
(0.0237)
−0.0583*
(0.0306)
−0.0788**
(0.0313)
−0.0808***
(0.0310)
−0.105***
(0.0310)
Observations1,0811,0811,0811,0811,081
Log likelihood−2,411.41−2,429.96−2,409.82−2,408.03−2,382.37
AIC4,844.834,881.924,843.644,840.054,806.74
BIC4,899.674,936.774,903.474,899.884,911.44
Weighted?NoYesYesYesYes
  • Note: Standard errors are in parentheses. Dependent variable: log of maximum one-way distance willingly traveled on a typical birdwatching day trip.

  • * p< 0.05;

  • ** p< 0.01;

  • *** p< 0.001.