Regular ArticleProductivity and Undesirable Outputs: A Directional Distance Function Approach
Abstract
Undesirable outputs are often produced together with desirable outputs. This joint production of good and bad outputs is typically ignored in traditional measures of productivity since “prices” are typically unavailable for bad outputs. Here we introduce a directional distance function and use it as a component in a new productivity index that readily models joint production of goods and bads, credits firms for reductions in bads and increases in goods, and does not require shadow prices of bad outputs. This index, as an empirical example shows, solves the problem caused by the joint production of good and bad outputs, and provides a practical managerial tool.
References (0)
Cited by (2205)
A unified framework for nonperforming loan modeling in bank production: An application of data envelopment analysis
2024, Omega (United Kingdom)The aim of this paper is to conduct a comparative analysis of three environmental approaches in the context of a bank production framework, considering the presence of nonperforming loans (NPLs). Specifically, we examine banks' inefficiency levels using the "by-production technology," "joint-weak disposable technology," and "material balanced technology." To ensure comparability within a directional slack inefficiency framework, we propose a two-step procedure. The study is based on a sample of 379 prominent banks operating in the United States from 2003 to 2017. Our findings reveal that the material balance and by-production technologies result in estimated inefficiency measures with higher sensitivity compared to the estimator utilizing the joint-weak disposable technology. Additionally, we identify distinct properties among the estimators, emphasizing their unique characteristics for modeling nonperforming loans. Finally, our paper sheds light on the differences between the three estimators in relation to banks' inefficiency levels, considering the incorporation of nonperforming loans in the production process.
The ‘Healthcare Access and Quality Index’ revisited: A fuzzy data envelopment analysis approach
2024, Expert Systems with ApplicationsNowadays, health systems comprise a series of resources structured to provide healthcare services to meet our health needs. However, premature deaths still occur. To quantify and understand personal healthcare conditions affecting such amenable mortality, the Healthcare Access and Quality Index (HAQI) was put forward, evaluating 195 countries and territories since 1990. Nevertheless, the literature acknowledges a series of limitations of this framework, such as the drawbacks of using principal component analysis to aggregate individual indicators, the absence of control for financing and environmental conditions, and the presence of a substantial degree of data uncertainty. Accordingly, we propose a methodological alternative to the computation of the HAQI using a novel fuzzy Data Envelopment Analysis model to handle the aforementioned shortcomings. We also propose its extension towards the quantification of efficiency (E-HAQI) – in the sense of value for money – by incorporating financial aspects as modelling inputs. This way, we contribute with innovative modelling approaches that can also deal with the high degree of data uncertainty. Furthermore, in a second-stage analysis, the impact of key exogenous factors on healthcare access and quality is assessed via non-parametric hypothesis testing. Our results show positive and significant correlations of both the revisited HAQI and E-HAQI with the original HAQI 2016 dataset. They also reveal a better use of resources by European and Oceanian countries and territories than by Sub-Saharan African ones. Concerning contextual determinants, socio-demographic development, human development, and the type of health system were found to be statistically significant drivers of healthcare access and quality efficiency.
Assessing the environmental efficiency with complex structure and component processes: An empirical analysis of regional industries in China
2024, Expert Systems with ApplicationsOver recent decades, China’s economy has continued to develop steadily and rapidly, contributing to a large environmental cost. Therefore, many researchers propose various methods to evaluate environmental efficiency to deal with these serious issues accurately. This paper is the first to evaluate environmental efficiency using a model featuring not only a parallel structure with three component processes (primary, secondary, and tertiary industries) in the first stage but also a sewage treatment process in the second stage. Simultaneously, we propose radial but also nonradial versions of the Environmental Multiple Variable Return to Scale (EMVRS) model. These two models both consider shared inputs as well as shared outputs, and the proportion of the shared inputs and shared outputs utilized in each component process is assumed to be unknown. Additionally, we further analyze the factors influencing environmental efficiency by utilizing the Tobit model. The results when EMVRS is applied to Chinese provinces can be divided into 3 parts: (1) Most provinces do not purify wastewater appropriately contributing to the bad environmental efficiency. (2) The efficiency values of the three industry types are similar or identical to each other in most provinces. (3) The population of people employed negatively impacts environmental efficiency.
Resilience, efficiency fluctuations, and regional heterogeneity in disaster: An empirical study on logistics
2024, Socio-Economic Planning SciencesWhile resilience analysis can provide important insights into risk management strategies, research gaps exist in terms of logistics efficiency, regional economic environment, and spatial clustering patterns. Therefore, our study capitalizes on the dramatic variations in logistics activities among regions during COVID-19 to examine regional logistics resilience in the disaster and explore potential spatial clustering patterns. We measure regional logistics resilience through changes in performance outcomes, specifically efficiency fluctuation. To analyze spatial clustering patterns, (regional heterogeneity) presented by logistics efficiency, we propose a new multi-stage approach that integrates the data envelopment analysis with the K-medoids algorithm and analyzes data from the Chinese logistic industry. The results reveal that efficiency fluctuations exhibit distinct spatial distribution characteristics, with more pronounced negative fluctuations in areas of important logistics activities nodes and islands, and more widespread negative trends in coastal areas. Moreover, regions with high freight volumes and logistics specialization demonstrate a sustained high level and quality of logistics efficiency. Furthermore, consumption capacity and economic development appear to positively influence fluctuations in logistics efficiency. The findings hold implications for enhancing regional logistics resilience in the disaster and contribute valuable insights to regional logistics risk management.
Multicriteria panel-data directional distances and the efficiency measurement of multidimensional higher education systems
2024, Omega (United Kingdom)In this paper, we introduce the notion of multicriteria-based directional distance determination for estimating the efficiency of decision units under different (and sometimes conflicting) interests and objectives. Different objectives are interpreted as different dimensions of a production system. Multidimensional industries, such as the Higher Education system, usually have clear preference structures and value judgments over teaching, research and service (outreach), leading to ranking differences for countries and organizations based on policy perspectives, production compensations, substitutions or complementation. We develop this framework based on the non-compensatory reasoning of outranking multicriteria methods to determine the most practical directional vector for the output expansion of Higher Education and support a multidimensional efficiency measurement. The numerical application using panel data illustrates policy-directed European countries based on the three dimensions of higher education. A similar understanding can be extended for determining directional efficiency for service units based on other multicriteria methods and heuristics.
Accuracy of Deterministic Nonparametric Frontier Models with Undesirable Outputs
2024, European Journal of Operational ResearchThe accuracy of deterministic nonparametric frontier models with desirable outputs has been extensively investigated. However, research on the models’ accuracy in the presence of undesirable outputs is almost nonexistent, though applications in this regard are abundant. This paper evaluates the accuracy of seven representative deterministic nonparametric frontier models in dealing with undesirable outputs. The experimental design employs Monte Carlo simulation and translog production functions across a wide range of settings. We find that the integration of undesirable outputs lowers model accuracy. All seven models display robust performance under different returns-to-scale assumptions. Outputs correlation has a positive effect on model performance. Using a large sample can improve the models’ accuracy except for the range-adjusted measure model. The models’ accuracy is most sensitive to noise at low noise levels. Endogeneity has a negative effect on the models’ accuracy, but depreciation of accuracy is minor at low to medium endogeneity levels. Heteroskedasticity leads to improved performance. Overall, the experimental results support the usage of the by-production approach and strongly disfavor the range-adjusted measure approach and the hyperbolic approach. The directional distance function method has an edge for large samples, if the objective is to identify top and bottom units. Another approach, treating undesirable outputs as inputs, is dominated by other methods. The ranking of the methods is generally robust to the variations of returns-to-scale, sample size, noise, outputs correlation, endogeneity, and heteroskedasticity. We also show that the slacks-based measure under the by-production framework has better performance than the Färe–Grosskopf–Lovell index proposed in literature.